FLIRTing with the Crowds

Collaboration and sociality in design, business & technology

FLIRTing with the Crowds header image 2

Tired of networking socially?

February 9th, 2007 · 3 Comments

I am. With the torrent of social media networks available, the incentive to sign up for yet another service that would bring you tons of new friends and make your life a constant bliss (should you ever log in again after registering) is slowly wearing out.

That doesn’t mean thinking that I already have too many contacts and would be totally happy with my existing buddies. Not even close. Just today I engaged in a very useful and enjoyable e-mail exchange with Mr. Langenberg, who is the author of an article that comes very close to my thesis subject. After inquiring for the working paper, I got a lightning fast response from him, and after explaining my thesis subject in a bit more detail, he was kind enough to share with me a collection of additional readings he thought might be useful for my studies. Most of the articles seem very promising and I doubt I would ever have found them just by soloing through our school’s journal search tools.

Yesterday I didn’t even know the guy. Today he had personally helped me a great deal with his advice and we had developed a mutual interest for each other’s research fields. That’s social networking at its best.

But to the point. The thing I was talking about at the start of this post is the endless cycle of identical processes that I have to go through every time I register for a service: pour out all the information about myself from my first kiss through my favorite bands to whether or not I believe in the existence of extraterrestrial beings. Then I need to pinpoint all the locations I have visited in the world and upload all my pictures from along the way. This all takes enormous amounts of time, wastes bandwidth and feels frustrating, and I’m not even a member in that many networks. The same is true with instant messaging: ICQ, yahoo, Skype, MSN, etc. In order to stay in touch with all of my buddies from different countries & continents, I would have to keep all of these on at all times. Again, a waste of resources and attention.

It isn’t any better with applying for jobs either. Actually, it’s worse. For every employer, I have to use their own unique web form for entering all my previous employers, titles, descriptions of responsibilities, education, language skills, etc. And not I only have to do it once for every employer, but once for every post I’m applying to. If I’m applying for three jobs at the same company, at worst I have to fill out the exact same forms three times within one session in front of my computer! This is not always the case, of course, but surprisingly many big and supposedly up-to-date companies have this kind of against-all-logic system currently in use.

The thing we need is services that can mash up data and user information from various different sources and be controlled by a universal user account. Service providers need to recognize this need and open their interfaces for data transfer between services. When I for example sign up for a new social network, I want to import my photos from flickr, my destinations from ballofdirt.com as well as my work experience from LinkedIn and my link feed from del.icio.us. Otherwise it will eventually be impossible for me to add up on new services and the limit of how many networks I can participate is reached pretty quickly.

Jon Udell noted the same phenomenon in his article on social network fatigue when quoting Gary McGraw: “People keep asking me to join the LinkedIn network, but I’m already part of a network, it’s called the Internet”.

Could it be that some day the only network we need to register to is the web, and all our information will be there to use in all the different contexts we may come up with, with only one upload. Perhaps, but, as it seems now, not too soon.

Tags: society

3 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Joe Richards // Feb 12, 2007 at 3:25 pm

    Surely the problem is partially technical as well. Standard data formats for type of information don’t exist yet, so it’s difficult for website and social network operators to exchange data.

    Added to this, the fact that most of them don’t _want_ you to, and you end up with messy solutions like websites pretending to login to others, and try to read the relevant info off each other’s pages. Works fine, until someone changes the layout of their site and the others break…

  • 2 sami.viitamaki // Feb 15, 2007 at 2:34 pm

    Very true. I am aware of the complex technical issues and lack of common standards and this is a problem not easily tackled with, as it requires coordination and cooperation on a massive scale, not to talk about downright resistance.

    Anyway, I will still keep looking forward for these kinds of developments as we do live in an environment that continuously becomes more complex and harder to manage.

  • 3 Alan // Feb 16, 2007 at 5:25 am

    “I’m already part of a network, it’s called the Internet.”
    Thanks Jon!

    Crowdsourcing is an emerging cultural/business model, its slowly taking root, that’s pushing new frontiers and taking established forms of involvement and commerce for a joy ride and its only in its infancy.

    The future promises the ability to “click” into social/cultural/communicative and business realms without the limiting software barriers and programs that are diametrically apposed to intuitive human intercourse and healthy social business practices.

    Semantics and other terms like Web 3.0 have been bandied about as hype but I believe that once the technological frontiers are crossed, crowdsourcing will show that the acquisition of YouTube by Google was a baby step in an unfolding process that will goad industry leaders to reconsider strategies and reinvent their priorities.

    We are on the cusp of technological development that holds the promise of fulfilling dreams hardly imaginable.

    Here is one link that intimates such beginning developments:
    http://novaspivack.typepad.com/nova_spivacks_weblog/

    graph:
    http://novaspivack.typepad.com/RadarNetworksTowardsAWebOS.jpg

    Alan.

Leave a Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security text shown in the picture. Click here to regenerate some new text.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word